WEST VIRGINIA

                            SUPREME COURT OF APPEALS

                                                         OPINIONS                     

Spring 2000 
 Please note that the Opinions on the Spring  2000 list are now available in PDF as well as  HTML format. As always, opinions on this page are subject to clerical corrections, modification and rehearing until final.

Filed Case No. Case Name
7/12/2000 27751 Dababnah v. WV Board of Medicine
6/23/2000 27658 State ex rel. Stewart v. Alsop, Judge
6/9/2000 27469 State ex rel. Parsons v. Zakaib, Jr., Judge
7/14/2000 27466 State ex rel. Lambert v. King, Judge
7/12/2000 27465 State ex rel. Ray v. Canady, Jr., Judge
7/10/2000 27463 Dean v. Town of Addison
7/7/2000 27460 Moore v. St. Joseph's Hospital of Buckhannon
3/31/2000 27458  State ex rel. Carenbauer v. Hechler, et al.
12/14/2000 27458.Dis State ex rel. Carenbauer v. Hechler, et al.
7/14/2000 27444 State ex rel. Valentine v. Watkins
7/14/2000 27444.Dis State ex rel. Valentine v. Watkins
6/8/2000 27439 State ex rel. Bolden v. Pancake, Judge
7/14/2000 27382 State of West Virginia v. Vance
7/14/2000 27381 Keplinger v. Virginia Electric and Power Co.
7/12/2000 27380 Graham v. Wallace, D.D.S., M.S. 
7/20/2000 27380.Dis Graham v. Wallace, D.D.S., M.S. 
7/12/2000 27377 In Re: Tax Assessment Against American, etc.
7/12/2000 27374 WV Board of Medicine v. Shafer, M.D.
7/19/2000 27374.Dis WV Board of Medicine v. Shafer, M.D.
6/8/2000 27328 State ex rel. Canterbury v. Mineral Co. Comm.
7/14/2000 27327 State ex rel. Kaufman, Judge v. Zakaib, Judge
7/11/2000 27316 Czaja v. Czaja 
7/19/2000 27315 Sale v. Goldman, Mayor, City of Charleston
7/20/2000 27315.Con Sale v. Goldman, Mayor, City of Charleston
7/11/2000 27313 State of West Virginia v. Snodgrass
7/10/2000 27311 Taylor v. Cabell Huntington Hospital
7/20/2000 27311.Dis Taylor v. Cabell Huntington Hospital
5/8/2000 27264 Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Pitts
6/28/2000 27264.Con Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Pitts
7/12/2000 27259 City of Philippi v. Weaver
12/13/2000 27259.Dis City of Philippi v. Weaver
6/27/2000 27258 State of West Virginia v. McGuire 
7/19/2000 27258.Dis State of West Virginia v. McGuire 
6/12/2000 27257 Vieweg, Commissioner, v. Gatson, Clerk, et al.
6/8/2000 27255 State ex rel. Meadows v. Stephens, Judge
4/24/2000 27061 State ex rel. H., Jeanette v. Pancake, Judge
7/13/2000 27056 Boggess v. WCD and Union Carbide 
12/5/2000 27056.Con Boggess v. WCD and Union Carbide 
7/20/2000 27056.Con Boggess v. WCD and Union Carbide 
7/12/2000 27054 State of West Virginia v. Kitchen
7/10/2000 27000 State of West Virginia v. Green
7/12/2000 26988 Wingrove, v. WCD and Consolidation Coal 
6/14/2000 26963 State of West Virginia v. Nett
6/28/2000 26963.Dis State of West Virginia v. Nett
7/14/2000 26962 Stone v. St. Joseph's Hospital of Parkersburg
7/14/2000 26962.Con Stone v. St. Joseph's Hospital of Parkersburg
10/20/2000 26962.Con Stone v. St. Joseph's Hospital of Parkersburg
7/10/2000 26954 State ex rel. Evans v. Frye, Judge
6/16/2000 26915 In Re: Emily and Amos B. 
7/20/2000 26915.Con In Re: Emily and Amos B. 
7/10/2000 26906 In Re: Extradition of Andrew Chandler
7/12/2000 26905 Stout v. Stout
7/10/2000 26904 J.M., L.M., etc. v. Webster Co. Board of Ed.
7/20/2000 26904.Con J.M., L.M., etc. v. Webster Co. Board of Ed.
7/11/2000 26903 State ex rel. WV DHHR v. Gibson
7/12/2000 26902 Dababnah v. Dababnah 
7/12/2000 26901 Barthelemy v. WV Dept. of Corrections, etc. 
6/12/2000 26900 Zelenka v. City of Weirton, et al. 
7/20/2000 26900.Dis Zelenka v. City of Weirton, et al. 
7/20/2000 26900.Con Zelenka v. City of Weirton, et al. 
7/12/2000 26899 State of West Virginia v. Sapp, Jr. 
7/7/2000 26898 State of West Virginia v. Parr
5/5/2000 26854 State ex rel. Gill v. Irons, Judge
7/12/2000 26853 Saunders v. Tri-State Block Corp.
6/12/2000 26852 State of West Virginia v. Ramsey
3/24/2000 26851 State ex rel. P., Michael v. Miller, Judge
7/19/2000 26850 Roberts v. Consolidation Coal Company
7/12/2000 26849 State of West Virginia v. McIntosh
7/13/2000 26849.Dis State of West Virginia v. McIntosh
1/28/2000 26847 State ex rel. Crafton v. Burnside
2/2/2000 26847.Dis State ex rel. Crafton v. Burnside
1/28/2000 26845 State ex rel. Davis v. Viewig
2/24/2000 26844 State ex rel. DHHR, et al. v. Hill, Judge
6/14/2000 26841 Tabor v. Gatson, Clerk, et al. 
4/25/2000 26840 Robertson v. B A Mullican Lumber
10/20/2000 26840.Con Robertson v. B A Mullican Lumber
7/12/2000 26837 State ex rel. Barden and Robeson v. Hill, Judge
6/14/2000 26835 State ex rel. McLaughlin v. Vickers, Judge
5/4/2000 26832 State ex rel. Hall v. Liller, Warden
6/16/2000 26743 Farmer v. Knight
7/19/2000 26743.Dis Farmer v. Knight
6/8/2000 26742 In Re: B., George Glen, Jr. 
4/24/2000 26738 State ex rel. Davidson v. Hoke, Judge
7/19/2000 26738.Con State ex rel. Davidson v. Hoke, Judge
7/7/2000 26737 Bryan v. Westfield Insurance Co.
6/9/2000 26736 Minshall v. Health Care & Retirement
7/20/2000 26736.Dis Minshall v. Health Care & Retirement
10/20/2000 26736.Dis Minshall v. Health Care & Retirement Corp.
4/24/2000 26734 Capitol Chrysler-Plymouth v. Megginson
7/20/2000 26734.Con Capitol Chrysler-Plymouth v. Megginson
5/5/2000 26733 State of West Virginia v. Harris
5/23/2000 26733.Con State of West Virginia v. Harris
5/4/2000 26732 State of West Virginia v. Legg
6/12/2000 26731 Clay Foodland v. WV DHHR, et al. 
6/22/2000 26731.Dis Clay Foodland v. WV DHHR, et al. 
6/21/2000 27256 McCartney v. Lester, et al.
6/16/2000 26660 Stout v. Ravenswood Aluminum Corp.
4/24/2000 26659 Banfi v. American Hosp. for Rehabilitation
7/14/2000 26658 Bass v. Coltelli-Rose
7/19/2000 26658.Con Bass v. Coltelli-Rose
10/2/2000 26658.Dis Bass v. Coltelli-Rose
6/14/2000 26657 State of West Virginia v. Walker
7/20/2000 26657.Con State of West Virginia v. Walker
6/28/2000 26657.Dis State of West Virginia v. Walker
6/16/2000 26651 Lively v. Rufus, et al. 
6/14/2000 26650 Cupano v. WV Insurance Guaranty Assoc.
6/28/2000 26650.Dis Cupano v. WV Insurance Guaranty Assoc.
6/16/2000 26649 State of West Virginia Catlett
7/20/2000 26649.Dis State of West Virginia Catlett
5/5/2000 26638 State ex rel. WV DHHR v. K., Michael G.
7/11/2000 26636 Dalton v. Dalton
1/28/2000 26635 Expedited Trans. Systems, Inc.  v. Viewig
5/5/2000 26634 Korzun v. Yi
1/28/2000 26604 Bd. of Ed. of Kan. Cty. v. Quincy Coal, et al.
6/14/2000 26603 Rose v. Thomas Memorial Hospital 
6/28/2000 26603.Con Rose v. Thomas Memorial Hospital 
1/16/2001 26603.Dis Rose v. Thomas Memorial Hospital 
6/12/2000 26602 Cahill, et al. v. Mercer Co. Board of Ed.
7/10/2000 26601 Mingo Co. Redevelopment v. Green, et al. 
7/14/2000 26601.Dis Mingo Co. Redevelopment v. Green, et al. 
4/25/2000 26600 Mercer Co. Board of Ed. v. Townsend
7/20/2000 26600.Dis Mercer Co. Board of Ed. v. Townsend
5/5/2000 26573 State of West Virginia v. Bruffey
5/8/2000 26568 State of West Virginia v. Poling
5/10/2000 26568.Dis State of West Virginia v. Poling
6/28/2000 26567 Baker v. Board of Ed., County of Hancock
7/13/2000 26567.Dis Baker v. Board of Ed., County of Hancock
3/24/2000 26566 Easterling v. American Optical Corp., et al.
6/8/2000 26565 UB Services v. Gatson, et al. 
4/26/2000 26564 State of West Virginia v. Hayhurst
2/18/2000 26563 Senkus v. Moore, et al. 
7/10/2000 26561 Thompson v. Branches-Domestic Violence 
6/23/2000 26560 State of West Virginia v. Lewis
6/14/2000 26559 Estate of Hulda Davis v. Farmers Mutual Ins. 
6/28/2000 26559.Con Estate of Hulda Davis v. Farmers Mutual Ins. 
6/23/2000 26558 Iafolla v. Trent, et al. 
6/28/2000 26558.Dis Iafolla v. Trent, et al. 
6/16/2000 26437 Dalton v. Doe
1/12/2001 26437.Dis Dalton v. Doe
7/14/2000 26432 Armor v. Lantz
7/13/2000 26356 In Re: Hearing Losses I , etc.
7/12/2000 26351 Ingram v. City of Princeton
7/12/2000 26351.Con Ingram v. City of Princeton
4/12/2000 26218.Dis Bowers v. Wurzburg, et al.
6/21/2000 26210 McCloud v. Salt Rock Public Service District
3/1/2000 26197.Con Thacker v. WCD & Steel of WV
7/10/2000 26111 Vargo v. Pine 
7/20/2000 26111.Dis Vargo v. Pine 
12/13/2000 26111.Con Vargo v. Pine 
1/12/2000 25979.Dis Holmes v. BOE of Berkeley Co., etc.
7/13/2000 25956.Con Stevens v. WV Institute of Technology, etc.
6/28/2000 25951.Dis Shroades v. Food Lion, Inc., et al.
6/28/2000 25898.Con Flint, et al. v. Bd. of Ed., County of Harison
1/12/2000 25863.Dis Marsch, et al. v. Am. Elec. Power, et al.
1/12/2000 25844.Con State of West Virginia v. Swafford
3/10/2000 25831 Reynolds v. City Hospital, Inc., et al.
4/21/2000 25831.Dis Reynolds v. City Hospital, Inc., et al.
4/21/2000 25814.Dis Patton, et al. v. Gatson, Clerk 
6/9/2000 25814.Con Patton, et al. v. Gatson, Clerk 
2/18/2000 25539 Mitchell v. Broadnax
4/21/2000 25539.Con Mitchell v. Broadnax
10/20/2000 25539.Con Mitchell v. Broadnax
6/8/2000 25404.Dis State of West Virginia v. Catlett
3/1/2000 25336.Dis Poling, et al. v. Poling, Executrix 
2/16/2000 25325.Dis Meadows v. Wal-Mart Stores, etc. 
6/9/2000 25325.Con Meadows v. Wal-Mart Stores, etc. 
7/20/2000 24636.Dis Wade v. Chengappa, M.D., et al. 
2/18/2000 24483 Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Sayre

Monday, March 05, 2001 01:36 PM