Requests for Oral Presentation
and
Petitions for Appeal
January 13, 2000
1. State of West Virginia v. Jahmal Davis, No. 992977. Defendant appeals
his conviction for malicious assault for which he was sentenced to an
indeterminate term of not less than 2 nor more than 10 years in the State
Penitentiary. He seeks a reversal of his conviction or, in the alternative, a
new trial.
Accept for Motion Docket
2. State of West Virginia v. Lynis N. Ellerbe, No. 992978. Defendant
appeals from his jury convictions of aggravated robbery, attempted kidnaping
and wanton endangerment with a firearm. He seeks a reversal of his
convictions.
Refuse Petition 4-1
(Starcher, J.)
3. State of West Virginia v. Jamall L. Smith, No. 992983. Defendant
appeals from his conviction for malicious assault for which he received a
sentence of 2 to 10 years in the State Penitentiary. Defendant seeks a
reversal of his conviction.
Refuse Petition 4-1
(Scott, J.)
4. Leslie S. Stone v. Jackson County BOE, No. 992984. Plaintiff appeals
from the summary judgment awarded in favor of the Board of Education on
plaintiff's Mandolidis, wrongful discharge and contract claims. Plaintiff seeks
a reversal of that decision and requests a remand of this action to the circuit
court for trial.
Refuse Petition 4-1
(McGraw, J.)
5. State of West Virginia v. Melody Onapolis, No. 992982. Defendant
appeals from a pretrial ruling of the circuit court denying defendant's motion
to dismiss the indictment for failure to give her a speedy trial under the
Interstate Agreement on Detainers. Defendant seeks a dismissal of her
indictment.
Grant Petition 4-1
(Maynard, C.J.)
6. State of West Virginia v. Clyde W. Shaw, No. 992986. Defendant
appeals from his 2 felony convictions for DUI third offense and driving while
revoked for DUI third offense. He was sentenced to 1 to 3 years and fined
$5,000 on each, said sentences to run consecutively.
Refuse Petition 5-0
7. State of West Virginia v. Allah Jamaa Wallace, No. 992989. Defendant
appeals from his conviction for battery of a police officer for which he was
committed to The Industrial Home for Youth at Salem for a period of one
year.
Accept for Motion Docket
8. Bank One, West Virginia Wheeling, N.A. v. Virginia G. Collins, No.
992996. Plaintiff petitions this Court for a review of a certified question.
Refuse Petition 3-2
(Davis, J., Scott, J.)
9. Marjorie Verba, Estate v. David Ghaphery, M.D., No. 992998. Plaintiff
appeals from the circuit court's order reducing the verdict in this medical
malpractice action pursuant to the medical malpractice cap of W.Va. Code
55-7B-8. Plaintiff seeks a reinstatement of the full verdict.
Accept for Motion Docket
10. Cabell County BOE v. Richard Baker, No. 992999. The petitioner,
Richard Baker, appeals from an order entered in the Circuit Court of
Kanawha County reversing a Level IV grievance decision of the West Virginia
Education and State Employees Grievance Board. The Circuit Court
determined that the case should be dismissed because the petitioner's
grievance was not timely filed.
Refuse Petition 3-2
(Starcher, J., McGraw, J.)
11. Hewitt M. Grasty, Jr. v. Howard Painter, Warden, No. 993000. The
petitioner, Hewitt M. Grasty, Jr., appeals from an order entered in the Circuit
Court of Fayette County denying him relief in habeas corpus. The petitioner,
who entered a plea of guilty to the offense of aggravated robbery, was
sentenced to a term of 40 years. The petitioner asserts that his counsel in the
underlying proceeding was ineffective and that his sentence was excessive.
Refuse Petition 4-1
(Starcher, J.)
12. Stella Jean Ables v. State Div. Of Human Resources, No. 993001. The
petitioner, Stella Jean Ables, appeals from an order entered in the Circuit
Court of Lewis County granting the Rule 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss filed by
the respondent Lewis County Board of Education. The petitioner,
representing the estates of five children who died in an intentionally-set
house fire, alleged that the Board's failure to report suspected abuse and
neglect constituted a factor in the children's death. The Circuit Court ruled,
however, that the reporting requirement did not create a private cause of
action against the Board.
Refuse Petition 3-2
(Starcher, J., McGraw, J.)
13. Joseph W. Cubbison v. Gary Miller, M.D., No. 993003. The petitioner,
Joseph W. Cubbison, appeals from an order entered in the Circuit Court of
Wood County dismissing his medical malpractice action. The Circuit Court
concluded that the action was barred by the two-year statute of limitations.
14. State of West Virginia v. Mary-Daniel McMillion, No. 993005.
Petitioners, Daniel R. and Mary E. McMillion, appeal from an order entered
in the Circuit Court of Harrison County upholding the issuance of a peace
bond against the petitioners by the Harrison County Magistrate Court. The
controversy arose from an altercation between the petitioners and their
daughter-in-law.
Accept for Motion Docket
15. Elbert Allison v. Hancock County BOE, No. 993015. The petitioner,
Elbert Allison, appeals from an order entered in the Circuit Court of
Kanawha County which affirmed an adverse Level IV decision of the West
Virginia Education and State Employees Grievance Board. The petitioner,
a Supervisor of Transportation employed by the respondent under a 240-day
contract, contends that, pursuant to principles of salary uniformity, he was
entitled to a 261-day contract.
Refuse Petition 4-1
( McGraw, J.)
16. William R. Dean v. The Town of Addison, No. 993016. The petitioner,
The Town of Addison, appeals from a summary judgment entered in the
Circuit Court of Webster County in favor of the respondents, William R.
Dean, et al. The Circuit Court ruled that a fire protection service fee adopted
by the Town, although constitutional upon its face, was unconstitutionally
applied, where the fees collected were used to provide fire protection to
property owners whose property was located outside the boundaries of the
city.
Accept for Motion Docket
17. Coastal Corporation v. Bean, Roebuck, Hall, No. 993018. Petitioner-
defendants, Allen Taylor and Robert Joliff, appeal from an order entered in
the Circuit Court of Wood County finding them jointly and severally liable,
along with Bean, Roebuck, Hall & Associates, for certain debts associated
with the development of a leasehold interest. Specifically, the Circuit Court
concluded that the petitioners were general partners in a joint venture with
Bean, Roebuck, Hall & Associates and were, therefore, liable for the debts
incurred by BRH&A. The petitioners contend, however, that they were
passive investors only and were, thus, not liable.
Accept for Motion Docket